"The Importance of AI in War is Comparable to the Birth of Language"

Report Content

Reference News Network, November 17 report According to the French magazine "Le Point" website on November 14, neither benevolent savages nor natural fighters. In the recently published book "Humans Created War," anthropologist Jean-Claude Faure-Leveque proposes a bold third perspective: collective violence has gradually formed over millions of years, stemming from the interaction of family, weapons, and language.

This former officer of the French Air and Space Force and collaborative researcher at the Natural History Museum believes that war is a unique gradual product of the human lineage, rooted long before the advent of agricultural societies. As for artificial intelligence (AI), it may be the most far-reaching invention affecting war since the birth of language. Here are the interview contents.

War is a Long Construction

Le Point reporter asked: If war is neither a recent cultural invention nor a simple biological instinct, what does your formula "war is a long construction" actually mean?

Faure-Leveque replied: Three things have accumulated over a long time. First, social evolution: the emergence of stable partners, involving kinship and family, appeared very early in human lineage history. Second, tools. When humans invented tools, they created things that made killing easier. Finally, language. This extraordinary invention multiplied everything humans did. It allowed people to organize conflicts and enhance combat effectiveness through tactics. These three components emerged successively, accumulated, and reinforced each other.

Question: Your theory has three driving factors: family and kin networks, weapons, and language. Why is family, rather than resource scarcity, territorial disputes, or mate competition, the foundation of human conflict?

Answer: The latter are direct triggers, incidental reasons: people go to war at a certain moment for a specific reason. The triggers for conflicts in history have continually increased, and the weight of different triggers varies across different eras. Family, however, is a structural reason. It is a form of social organization that makes the occurrence of conflict possible.

Question: You suggest that upright walking "liberated the hands," preparing humans for armed combat. How should this be understood? Academia generally believes that upright walking is for adapting to movement, making tools, and transporting objects.

Answer: I am talking about pre-adaptation. A certain evolutionary trait was originally evolved for one function and later repurposed. Once the hands were freed, humans could make tools, that is, weapons, and use them. Of course, the evolutionary purpose of upright walking was never for war. But once upright, the hands had new uses, including fighting.

Question: In traditional societies, revenge is the main motive for conflict, and you link revenge with language.

Answer: This is my personal view; I have not seen similar discussions elsewhere. Revenge is a complex emotion that cannot be separated from language. Animals can remember companions: animals raised by humans from a young age will be attached to their owners for life. But this is only immediate emotion. To seek revenge by killing the enemy's wife and children and meticulously planning revenge actions is a behavior unique to humans. It requires a person to detach from the present and imagine the future, and this ability is generally believed to rely on language.

AI is More Than Just a Weapon

Question: You discuss military artificial intelligence, drones, cyberattacks, and the temptation to remove humans from the decision-making chain at the end of your book. Has war now extended into digital space, marking a historic break, or is it the latest stage of a long process that began with the first wooden stick?

Answer: They should be viewed separately. Drones are a continuation of weapon technology and are not even considered high-end technology: they are inexpensive, structurally simple, and can be mass-produced. It is not difficult to equip drones with intelligent modules, which is precisely where their efficiency lies. They bring about changes at the tactical level on the battlefield, and at the operational level, they may be similar to conventional warhead ballistic missiles.

Artificial intelligence, however, is completely different: it is not just a weapon but a reshaping of language and planning capabilities. Its importance may be comparable to the birth of language—only language took millions of years to gradually form, while artificial intelligence has rapidly developed in just a few decades.

Question: Specifically, how will artificial intelligence change warfare?

Answer: The changes will be profound, covering the entire military chain, from weapon production to command systems. One can imagine that a certain country may emerge far ahead, becoming unchallengeable. Artificial intelligence will completely rewrite many things.

Question: You say there are no so-called bad genes, nor guilty cultures, but violence is our evolutionary heritage. Is there any way for us to completely eliminate war, rather than just manage it?

Answer: The traditional view is that if war is innate, it cannot be eradicated; if it is a cultural product, there is still hope. My book has a rather pessimistic tone: this analytical framework does not provide a quick way to eliminate war. There is good news and bad news.

The good news is that war is a social behavior, and social behavior is much more malleable than innate instincts. Both aggression and cooperation have genetic components, but the behavior of war itself is social. This also explains the vast differences between Homo sapiens, chimpanzees, and bonobos, and how the forms of war change with the times. The bad news is that war is deeply rooted in our organizational methods and the way we think about power dynamics, even embedded in structures like the state. War is costly, yet it is a relatively efficient way to resolve conflicts. Anthropologist Margaret Mead also said: merely "forgetting" war is not enough; we need to replace it with something else.

Some changes are already occurring, such as population decline. With the reversal of population structure and aging, the number of potential combatants will decrease around 2050, and the balance of conflicts will change accordingly. This will have an impact, but I do not believe it will lead to a better world.

Question: Can we imagine a completely cooperative world without war?

Answer: I don't know. We are not a species like bonobos that rarely engage in war. Humans and bonobos have been evolving separately for six million years, and humans cannot actively plan and replicate their state. The three major elements still exist: society, weapons, and language. In terms of weapons, the trend of technological advancement is difficult to reverse; regarding language, we still need to see the direction of artificial intelligence; the remaining social aspect is the only space where we can take proactive action, after all, war is a social behavior. As for where the solution lies, I cannot provide an answer. (Translated by Pan Ge Ping)

Classification
Analytical Domain
Strategic
Primary Category / Secondary Categories
Strategic Assessment / Political-Military
SALUTE Report
Size
Not applicable
Activity
Discussion on the impact of AI on warfare and its historical context
Location
Unit
French Air and Space Force
Time
November 14, 2023
Equipment
Artificial IntelligenceDrones
Summary

The report highlights the insights of anthropologist Jean-Claude Fabiani-Leveque on the evolution of warfare, emphasizing the transformative role of artificial intelligence. He argues that AI could reshape military strategies and capabilities, akin to the historical significance of language. The discussion reflects on the interplay of social structures, tools, and language in the development of warfare.

Key Facts
  • AI is considered a significant advancement in warfare, comparable to the invention of language.
  • The evolution of warfare is linked to social structures, tools, and language.
  • The impact of AI on military operations could lead to a nation gaining overwhelming advantages.