German military shuts gates to Chinese cars over spy fears

Report Content

Soldiers driving some Chinese-made cars from BYD, Nio and Geely are being stopped at the gates of sensitive German military sites and told to park outside and walk in, over concerns about what the vehicles’ cameras and sensors could record.

Der Spiegel first reported on Nov. 10 that lists circulating inside the Bundeswehr name specific Chinese models barred from facilities classified as security areas. Bloomberg, citing people familiar with a nonpublic counterintelligence assessment, reported that security officials judged the risk of espionage through signals picked up by drones and cars to be too great.

Germany’s Defense Ministry has pushed back on the idea of a brand ban. Spokesperson Col. Mitko Müller told a government press conference on Nov. 11 that the restriction covers connected vehicles in general and that local security officers set the access rules site by site. A connected car could be kept out of one restricted zone but still allowed to park in a lot farther from sensitive buildings.

That means there is no single published list of banned models, and the ministry hasn’t said whether brands beyond BYD, Nio and Geely are affected. Geely’s reach in Germany goes well beyond its own badge, through Volvo, Polestar, Lynk & Co, Zeekr, Lotus and its joint ownership of Smart with Mercedes-Benz.

The ministry named cameras, microphones, radar and ultrasonic sensors as the equipment behind the concern. The same hardware that helps with parking and driver monitoring could, near a barracks, map layouts, movements and equipment.

There is so far no publicly substantiated evidence that any of the affected models actually sent sensitive Bundeswehr data to Chinese intelligence services, the Stuttgarter Zeitung reported. The limits are described as a precaution.

The evidence on drones is a different story. Der Spiegel quoted an insider as saying that German military counterintelligence, known as MAD, found forensic traces pointing to a possible outflow of data when it examined drones used by the Bundeswehr. The ministry hasn’t confirmed that claim.

It has confirmed the drone decision itself. In the future, “no Chinese models will be used anymore and existing systems will be replaced by national or European products,” a ministry spokesperson told Der Spiegel. According to sources cited by the magazine, the Bundeswehr has thousands of Chinese-made drones in use.

Germany isn’t the first to act. Poland restricted Chinese-made vehicles at military facilities in February. In October, the U.S. military barred privately owned BYD vehicles from Kadena Air Base in Okinawa, Japan, citing the same kinds of sensors. In Norway, Chinese-owned rental cars recorded a military drill.

The ministry said it is drawing up comprehensive rules for how connected vehicle systems can be used on its bases.

Content preview only. Full article available at source. View Full Article

Classification
Region
Europe
Analytical Domain
Strategic
Primary Category / Secondary Categories
Political-Military / Weapons & Equipment
SALUTE Report
Size
Thousands of Chinese-made drones in use by Bundeswehr
Activity
German military restricts access to sensitive sites for Chinese-made vehicles due to espionage concerns
Location
Germany
Unit
Bundeswehr (German Armed Forces)
Time
Reported on November 10 and 11, 2023
Equipment
Chinese-made vehiclesdronescamerasmicrophonesradarultrasonic sensors
Summary

The German military has restricted access for Chinese-made vehicles at sensitive sites due to espionage concerns, specifically naming models from BYD, Nio, and Geely. This decision follows a counterintelligence assessment indicating risks associated with the vehicles' sensors and cameras. The Bundeswehr currently operates thousands of Chinese-made drones, which will be replaced by national or European alternatives in the future.

Key Facts
  • German military restricts access for Chinese-made vehicles at sensitive sites.
  • Specific models from BYD, Nio, and Geely are barred from entry.
  • Thousands of Chinese-made drones are currently in use by the Bundeswehr.
  • The restrictions are described as a precaution against espionage.
  • Germany plans to replace Chinese drones with national or European products.