Toti pushes new foreign-built shipyard in the US to focus on frigates, large surface combatants

Report Content

WASHINGTON — William Toti, who has been nominated to serve as undersecretary of the Navy, has jumped off the “bandwagon of building ships in foreign yards,” instead pitching a new foreign-built shipyard in the US to construct frigates and other vessels. 

“We need [a] full portfolio of tools at our disposal,” Toti told lawmakers today at his nomination hearing before the Senate Armed Services Committee. “We have destroyers today doing frigate work, and the quickest way to get frigates in the United States Navy is to establish a new shipyard, world-class shipyard that’s focused just on those ships.” 

The comments come as foreign shipbuilding has emerged as a sticking point between Congress and the Trump administration, with the administration pushing for foreign yards to take on building at least a handful of US Navy vessels overseas, while Congress has sought to limit such efforts. 

Even so, Sen. Angus King, I-Maine, noted during today’s hearing that Toti’s proposal differed from building ships overseas, and that the discussion on the matter would continue. 

Toti said he backs using foreign shipyards, but only to construct auxiliary vessels. As for building more frigates and other surface combatants, he said the fastest way would be to have a foreign shipyard invest in a new shipyard in the US focused specifically on those vessels.

“Bringing the best shipyards in the world from the production standpoint, not from the quality of ship standpoint, are the Koreans and Japanese, and so by bringing those skills and by those processes into the United States, I think it only strengthens our workforce, and our industrial capacity, and that’s our only objective here,” Toti said. 

President Donald Trump and his administration have initiated several efforts to facilitate increased use of foreign yards to expand the US Navy. In August, Trump signed a memo pushing to broaden the so-called “Finland model” that is in place to build the Coast Guard’s Arctic Security Cutters. Under that model, the first vessels are constructed in Finland by foreign yards and follow-on ships are built in the US. 

According to the August memo, if foreign shipbuilders signed off on several strict conditions to move future work to the US, they could build up to two ships in three different ship classes at their home yards before those vessels would then move to the US. 

Additionally, the Trump administration has requested Congress to authorize the Navy to commission foreign shipyards to build two surface combatant and two non-combat auxiliary vessels in the fiscal 2027 National Defense Authorization Act. 

While the final version of the FY27 NDAA has yet to pass, the House’s version that passed in July includes a provision prohibiting building both warships and those that make up the combat logistics fleet in a foreign shipyard. The Senate Armed Services Committee’s version of the NDAA that passed in June similarly limits constructions of warships abroad. Even so, the measure does approve the procurement of up to two auxiliary ships from foreign shipyards, so long as they invest in the US maritime industrial base for production of additional vessels.

Separately, the Navy’s budget request asks for $1.85 billion in reconciliation funding to study using foreign yards to build US warships, and possibly go toward paying for an initial vessel built in Japan or South Korea, Breaking Defense previously reported.

Meanwhile, acting Secretary of the Navy Hung Cao told lawmakers in May that the US wants foreign yards to invest in the US, pointing to South Korean shipbuilder Hanwha which acquired a shipyard in Philadelphia in 2024. For his part, Chief of Naval Operations Adm. Daryl Caudle said the matter would receive a “full hard look” from him and his military advisors. 

“This is a complex topic. I need ships, I need them now, I need capacity,” Caudle told lawmakers on the Senate Armed Services Committee in May. “We have workforce limitations here. We have an industrial base that can’t support the load without being creative on modularity and these new construction techniques. This is an all-hands-on-deck thing.”

Toti previously served as a senior advisor to Deputy Secretary of Defense Steven Feinberg, and the Navy announced in May that he had started performing the duties of the Navy’s number two civilian. His nomination for the post was officially sent to the Senate in September. 

Classification
Region
North America
Analytical Domain
Strategic
Primary Category / Secondary Categories
Political-Military / Logistics
SALUTE Report
Size
Not specified
Activity
William Toti proposed establishing a new foreign-built shipyard in the US to focus on constructing frigates and large surface combatants.
Location
Washington
Unit
U.S. Navy
Time
During Toti's nomination hearing before the Senate Armed Services Committee
Equipment
frigateslarge surface combatantsauxiliary vessels
Summary

William Toti proposed establishing a new foreign-built shipyard in the US to focus on constructing frigates and large surface combatants during his nomination hearing in Washington. He emphasized the need for a full portfolio of naval capabilities and suggested that foreign shipyards could invest in US facilities for this purpose. The proposal aligns with ongoing discussions in Congress regarding military procurement and foreign shipyard involvement.

Key Facts
  • William Toti proposed a new shipyard in the US for frigate construction.
  • The proposal aims to enhance the US Navy's capabilities.
  • Toti supports using foreign shipyards for auxiliary vessels only.
  • The Trump administration has initiated efforts to increase foreign shipyard involvement in US Navy construction.
  • Congress is debating the extent of foreign shipyard involvement in military shipbuilding.