Western Media Article: Europe Accelerates Building Cyber Warfare Capabilities

Report Content

Reference News Network reported on November 16 The Spanish newspaper "El Mundo" published an article titled "Cyber Warfare Sweeps Europe" on November 13, authored by Pablo Pardo, with the content translated as follows:

Cyber warfare has arrived in Europe. Since the outbreak of the Russia-Ukraine conflict in 2022, within less than five years, significant cyberattacks capable of disrupting the daily lives of citizens have evolved from a theoretical possibility into initial sporadic incidents. Since October of this year, such attacks have become a common reality across the European continent.

Following two large-scale cyberattacks targeting supermarkets and blood banks, an unprecedented wave of cyber offensives affecting at least 15 countries erupted in the past week. This attack primarily involved a series of false bomb threats. Although these targets are not related to defense or security, they are crucial for the daily functioning of modern society. Affected targets included at least 34 flights within Europe, no fewer than 7,600 schools, various media organizations, train stations, hundreds of supermarkets, and even three blood banks.

It is evident that cyber warfare has become a reality. Based on these facts, it should also be noted that Dan Jarvis, the UK Minister of State for Security, issued advice to British citizens on October 22, urging them to stockpile enough food and drinking water to last for three days. Jarvis made this request not out of concern for conventional military operations, but due to the threat of cyberattacks—such attacks could paralyze essential services necessary for the normal functioning of the nation.

"Hunt Forward": Cyber Attacks Enter Reality

In fact, such attacks had already emerged as early as the beginning of 2022, when Russia attempted to weaken Ukraine's resistance capabilities on the eve of launching the war against it. Subsequently, as the intensity of attacks escalated, European countries had to take more proactive measures to protect critical infrastructure from cyber assaults.

As the threat escalated, the UK, which has taken the hardest stance against Russia among European powers, began to publicly disclose the existence of a type of cyber warfare operation. These operations extend the conflict beyond the virtual space into the unsettling realm of the real world, known as "Hunt Forward" operations.

These operations essentially involve deploying combat teams trained in cyber warfare and electronic warfare to countries currently under such attacks, even penetrating deep behind enemy lines. This deployment method helps enhance the defensive capabilities of allies while pushing the so-called "digital front" closer to enemy operational hubs. Conducting operations within enemy territory creates more opportunities for preemptive or retaliatory strikes and opens new pathways for infiltrating adversary systems. This is because cyber warfare is not entirely "virtual"; geographical location remains crucial, to the extent that military forces of various countries are willing to take the risk of violating the sovereignty of other nations to carry out such operations.

Tim Stevens, a professor of International Security at King's College London, explains: "To access a wireless network, you must be physically close to the buildings where those networks are located." Wireless networks have long been targets of attacks. In 2018, Russian intelligence parked a vehicle filled with electronic equipment near the headquarters of the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons in The Hague, attempting to access the building's wireless network, but this attempt was timely discovered and thwarted by Dutch intelligence.

According to the American security firm Volexity, in early 2022, Russian cyber spies successfully infiltrated the wireless network of an unnamed institution in Washington by hacking into computers in nearby buildings. In Ukraine, Russian personnel successfully disrupted local wireless networks simply by being near the target buildings.

It is understood that these forward-deployed European combat teams are typically stationed within allied countries, currently in places like Ukraine or Moldova, often close to the Russian border. This approach has two major advantages: geographical proximity and ease of protecting the host country's network systems. Stevens adds: "When you are inside the building where the network system is located, it is much easier to monitor or protect that network."

Independent Actions: Countries Deploying Separately

Such actions signify an escalation of defensive cyber warfare in Europe, as they directly bring the conflict to Russian territory. NATO had considered the possibility of such actions, but politically, it was almost unfeasible. Deploying these personnel in war-torn countries like Ukraine could be even more effective than deploying a tank brigade or a squadron of fighter jets, without provoking political tensions. The reason is simple: the movements of these personnel are not publicly known. The UK acknowledged conducting such operations years ago and is now making them public. The Times published an in-depth interview on the 9th with Mike Fairs, the highest commander of the UK's Cyber and Electromagnetic Defence Forces. Although the article did not explicitly state it, it implied that these "cyber soldiers" had carried out missions within Russia.

Jamie Macol, a researcher at the Royal United Services Institute, the world's oldest security and defense research organization based in London, pointed out: "As far as I know, the UK is the only European country that has acknowledged conducting 'Hunt Forward' operations." He noted that among NATO member states, only the US and Canada have carried out such operations besides the UK. According to this expert, the Netherlands, Nordic countries, Baltic states, and Poland also possess the capability to deploy specialized electronic warfare and cyber combat forces to third countries and conduct operations within those nations.

Additionally, multiple reports have mentioned France, which may also have deployed relevant forces in Ukraine. While the technological advantage of the US in this field is undeniable, both Stevens and Macol believe that European countries are fully capable of conducting such operations without support from Washington. Stevens explains: "The US advantage primarily lies in intelligence, rather than technological capability."

These operations are carried out independently by various countries, although collaboration may occur in some cases. Macol points out that NATO does not conduct such operations, "because of the organization's defensive nature." The EU's "Cyber Rapid Response Team," led by Lithuania, has taken a more proactive stance. Nevertheless, determining the true scale of these operations is almost impossible. As Stevens stated: "As far as we know, there is no so-called 'European unified plan'; each country decides independently whether to participate."

In any case, the existence of "Hunt Forward" operations, coupled with the almost daily occurrence of cyber sabotage activities, seems to confirm the viewpoint put forth by the former head of the UK's counterintelligence agency MI5, Eliza Manningham-Buller, last September: "The UK is likely already at war with Russia." (Translated by Wang Meng)

Classification
Region
Europe
Analytical Domain
Informational
Primary Category / Secondary Categories
Information Operations / Military Operations
SALUTE Report
Size
Not specified
Activity
Cyber warfare attacks targeting critical infrastructure and public services
Location
Europe
Unit
Various European nations' cyber defense units
Time
Since October 2023
Equipment
Cyber warfare teamsElectronic warfare equipment
Summary

Cyber warfare has escalated in Europe, with significant attacks affecting critical infrastructure and public services since October 2023. At least 15 countries have experienced these attacks, targeting flights, schools, and supermarkets. In response, European nations are deploying cyber defense units closer to conflict zones to enhance their capabilities against such threats.

Key Facts
  • Cyber attacks have become common in Europe since October 2023.
  • At least 15 countries were affected by a recent wave of cyber attacks.
  • Targets included flights, schools, media outlets, and supermarkets.
  • The UK government advised citizens to prepare for potential disruptions due to cyber threats.
  • European nations are deploying cyber warfare teams closer to conflict zones.