Suspicion of Fabrication in North Korea's November 4 Cluster Munition Test Photos Shakes Missile Assessments by Japan, the U.S., and South Korea

Report Content

Suspicion of Fabrication in North Korea's November 4 Cluster Warhead Test Photos Shakes Missile Assessments by Japan, the U.S., and South Korea

Regarding the photos of the cluster warhead test released by North Korea on November 4, NK News's analysis of satellite images and public footage has raised serious doubts. Some of the photos purportedly showing an attack on a runway are likely manipulated images from 2022. This does not mean that the warhead does not exist. However, without primary data to support the launch and effect assessment, it is impossible to determine the timing of operational deployment or accuracy of strikes.

What the Photos Indicate and What They Do Not

On November 1, North Korea announced that it had tested a cluster warhead to be mounted on tactical ballistic missiles and plans to make four types operational by the end of the year. Furthermore, in November, it also claimed to test a dispersal-type warhead using strategic cruise missiles. Cluster warheads are weapons that can dominate a wide area, particularly suited for surface targets such as runways, parking areas, and radar positions. Rather than improving the accuracy of individual missiles, it should be viewed as a concept aimed at saturating air defense positions in a short time.

However, the KCNA photos alone do not confirm warhead separation, dispersal of submunitions, or impact density. What the Japanese Ministry of Defense and U.S.-South Korean authorities should focus on is not the footage of launch flames, but rather the flight trajectories, impact areas, and before-and-after comparisons of satellite images using multiple sensors.

"Year-End Deployment" as Information Warfare

The suspicion of photo reuse does not serve as a basis for underestimating North Korea's capabilities, nor does it immediately justify the recognition of new weapons. Rather, what should be noted is the attempt to create a fait accompli of deployment by consecutively announcing ballistic missiles, cruise missiles, and air defense weapons in a short period. The recently reported change in the national flag's ratio is also said to be the first since the country's founding in 1948, indicating that Kim Jong-un's regime is re-editing not only military capabilities but also national symbols. However, the political implications of this change remain speculative at this point.

Practical Responses from Japan, the U.S., and South Korea

For those tasked with defending South Korean bases, air defense positions, and ports, preparations are necessary even if the operational performance of cluster warheads remains unverified. Treating the intercept target as a single warhead could lead to misjudging the widespread damage after dispersal. The Self-Defense Forces and U.S. military could subdivide data sharing from launch detection to damage assessment, allowing for verification of South Korea's runway recovery capabilities and the protection of sea lines of communication (SLOC) in the Sea of Japan in the same exercise.

Photos do not prove capabilities. However, the very information manipulation attempting to prove capabilities can serve as material for reading the opponent's operational intentions.

According to Takashi Tanaka, the core issue this time is not the performance of the cluster warhead, but the danger of unverifiable images preempting policy decisions. What Japan, the U.S., and South Korea should fear is not just believing North Korea's propaganda. After discerning the deception, there is also the risk of underestimating the actual threat as a backlash.

Key Information Sources

Classification
Region
East Asia & Pacific
Analytical Domain
Operational
Primary Category / Secondary Categories
Weapons & Equipment / Military Operations
Subcategory
New Weapon System
SALUTE Report
Size
Not specified
Activity
North Korea conducted a test of cluster munitions and is preparing to operationalize multiple types of missiles by the end of the year.
Location
North Korea
Unit
North Korean Armed Forces
Time
November 4, 2023
Equipment
cluster munitionstactical ballistic missilesstrategic cruise missiles
Summary

North Korea conducted a test of cluster munitions on November 4, 2023, raising concerns about the authenticity of the images released. The country aims to operationalize multiple types of missiles by the end of the year, although the actual effectiveness of the cluster munitions remains unverified. Japan, the U.S., and South Korea are advised to prepare for potential threats despite uncertainties regarding North Korea's capabilities.

Key Facts
  • North Korea released photos of a cluster munitions test on November 4, 2023.
  • There are suspicions that some images may have been altered from previous years.
  • North Korea plans to operationalize four types of cluster munitions by the end of the year.
  • The effectiveness of the cluster munitions remains unverified due to lack of primary data.
  • The report highlights the need for Japan, the U.S., and South Korea to prepare for potential threats.