US and Russia to oppose talks on limiting autonomous weapons

Report Content


Major arms producers the United States and Russia look set to oppose a push at a global meeting in Geneva this week to launch negotiations on legally binding rules for autonomous weapons, diplomats and rights groups said.

The rise of artificial intelligence has boosted development of drones, robots, tanks, submarines and other military hardware capable of killing without human involvement. Semi-autonomous, AI-assisted weapons have already been used in Ukraine, Sudan and the Middle East, despite ethical concerns.

The UN-hosted meeting from Monday is due to decide whether to start talks for a legally binding pact on prohibitions and regulations for Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems (LAWS). 

But while most of the 128 states party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons support that, major military nations including the U.S., Russia and Israel oppose it, arguing that existing humanitarian law is sufficient.

In a video message, the UN secretary-general urged states to agree to move towards negotiating a legally binding instrument including clear prohibitions and restrictions. 

“The nature of warfare is changing. New technologies — including autonomous weapon systems — present new humanitarian, legal, ethical and security challenges,” Antonio Guterres said. 

But Russia stymied the start of talks on Monday with its objection to a procedural rule allowing observers, including the EU and non-governmental organisations, to take the floor. Delegates including Ireland and Canada opposed that.

The International Committee of the Red Cross, along with the pope, has also warned of the dangers from autonomous weapons.

‘Dystopian reality’

“Machines should never be allowed to decide who lives and dies on a battlefield but that is the dystopian reality that is fast approaching,” said Verity Coyle from Human Rights Watch, which is also urging the Review Conference to take firm action.

Two diplomats told Reuters the discussions would be challenging but that a compromise may be found by the end of the week. All options are on the table, from legally binding to non-legally binding, as well as a hybrid agreement with both elements, one of the diplomats said.

Campaigners say autonomous weapons systems can behave unpredictably, raising the risk of fatal errors.

Anna Hehir, head of military AI governance at the Future of Life Institute – a US-based nonprofit organization focused on reducing the risks of advanced technologies, including AI — said LAWS were no longer science fiction, pointing to media reporting of early use of fully autonomous systems in Ukraine.

The U.S. favors guidelines over binding rules on LAWS, arguing that international law already provides a framework to govern warfare. It has proposed a five-year mandate for talks towards a non-binding agreement.

Hehir told Reuters the U.S. and Russia would probably seek to water down any outcome as they did in September with a text about autonomous weapons and their potential for harm. 

The chair of this week’s talks has proposed a two-year mandate to negotiate a legally binding protocol. 

The UK, Germany and France propose negotiations on an instrument that leaves open whether it would be legally binding or not, Coyle told Reuters.  

Classification
Region
Europe
Analytical Domain
Strategic
Primary Category / Secondary Categories
Political-Military / Weapons & Equipment
SALUTE Report
Size
128 states party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons
Activity
Opposition to negotiations on legally binding rules for autonomous weapons
Location
Geneva
Unit
United States, Russia, Israel
Time
This week
Equipment
Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems (LAWS)dronesrobotstankssubmarines
Summary

The United States and Russia oppose negotiations on legally binding rules for autonomous weapons at a global meeting in Geneva this week. Despite support from 128 states for such negotiations, major military nations argue that existing humanitarian law suffices. The UN secretary-general has called for clear prohibitions and restrictions on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems (LAWS), highlighting the changing nature of warfare due to new technologies.

Key Facts
  • The US and Russia oppose negotiations on autonomous weapons regulations in Geneva.
  • The UN secretary-general urges states to negotiate a legally binding instrument on autonomous weapons.
  • 128 states support negotiations, but major military nations oppose them, citing existing humanitarian law.
  • The US favors guidelines over binding rules and has proposed a five-year mandate for talks.
  • Russia blocked procedural rules allowing observers to participate in discussions.