Photos of North Korea's November 4th Concentrated Combat Unit Test with 2022 Images: Verification Procedures Questioned by Japan, the U.S., and South Korea
Tanaka TakashiPhotos of North Korea's November 4 Cluster Munitions Test Featuring 2022 Images: Verification Procedures Questioned by Japan, the U.S., and South Korea
Rating: ★★★★☆ The issue is not whether the missile was launched. According to verification by NK News, the photos distributed by North Korea claiming to show the "cluster munitions" test on November 4 reused images taken in 2022. If the reuse of the same images is confirmed, it would undermine the ability to prove the core issue of the separation and operation of the cluster munitions solely through photographs, regardless of whether the launch occurred.
Furthermore, the only information the author could verify from publicly available sources is that NK News reported on November 4 that North Korea announced the potential use of cluster munitions in tactical missiles, and on the same day, the South Korean Joint Chiefs of Staff detected "multiple missiles" heading east. From the public announcements by Japan, the U.S., and South Korea, there is no confirmed measurement data to support that the warhead was of a cluster type or that the submunitions were dispersed as planned. Therefore, "launch detection" and "success of the cluster munitions test" should not be treated with the same level of certainty.
Four Hurdles to Overcome Before Photos Can Serve as Evidence
The evidential power of photographs is not determined by their appearance. It is necessary to sequentially verify the original data's shooting date and equipment information, mountain ridges, roads, vegetation and seasons, the external shape of the launch vehicle and projectile, and frame-by-frame comparisons with past official photographs. The match with the 2022 images referenced in this report raises doubts at the final hurdle. Even with cropping, flipping, or recompression, the outlines of clouds, dirt on vehicles, and background features may remain.
However, this article does not have independent access to the original files, EXIF data, or all frames of the relevant KCNA photos. Therefore, the evaluation of photo reuse is astrong signal based on NK News's verification, and until third-party reproduction using the original image set and satellite images is completed, it will not be labeled as "confirmed." It is also erroneous to deny the launch itself solely based on the unnaturalness of the images.
Success in Propaganda and Success in Testing Are Different Matters
North Korea has the motivation to show a rapid pace of testing with a fourth test within the month, a prior commitment to deploy multiple cluster munitions by the end of the year, and a simultaneous stance of not engaging in dialogue. In a situation where they want to connect failures, limited successes, or tests that differ from plans to a narrative of "new capabilities emerging continuously," the reuse of existing footage is advantageous for both internal mobilization and external intimidation.
However, the decline in the reliability of the photos should not be used as evidence of zero capability. Cluster munitions can pose a threat to targets around airport runways, radar positions, ports, and urban areas. Even if the verification of the warhead's effectiveness is uncertain, the defense plans of Japan, the U.S., and South Korea, including alertness, recovery, and unexploded ordnance handling, should be examined with the most inconvenient possibilities in mind.
What Is Needed Is Triangulation
Future determinations should practically score statements, publicly available images, and external detections separately. First, the times, directions, number of flights, and falling sea areas reported by the South Korean Joint Chiefs of Staff, the Japanese Ministry of Defense, and the U.S. side should be cross-referenced. Second, new traces of the launch site, support vehicles, and firing ranges should be verified using commercial satellites. Third, image comparisons should confirm the continuity of warhead separation. Only when these three align can the evaluation be raised from "something was launched" to "the cluster munitions were tested as intended." The publicly available data around November 4 alone does not reach that stage.
Changes to the national flag should also be treated with the same discipline. NK News reported that the official site Naenara changed the aspect ratio of the flag, which has been in use since 1948, to 1:1.65. This change serves as an external signal to align with the appearance of a "normal state" and could also be an internal signal distancing itself from the designs of the Kim Il-sung era. However, verification against primary sources of legal documents and constitutional amendments ispending confirmation, and the discussion of symbols should not be used to substantiate military capabilities.
The true weakness is not that Japan, the U.S., and South Korea lack images. It is whether they can politically separate detected launches, unverified warhead performance, and necessary protective measures in the face of ambiguous photographs. Preventing the urgent sense of time created by the opponent's propaganda from dominating decision-making is fundamental to deterrence.
Sources and Verification Status
- NK News (November 4): North Korea's announcement of cluster munitions and expert evaluations.
- NK News (November 4): Report on the detection of multiple projectiles by the South Korean Joint Chiefs of Staff.
- NK News (November 12): Change in the flag ratio on Naenara. Legal basis is pending confirmation.
- Reuse of the 2022 photo: Based on image verification by NK News. Independent reproduction of original files and all photo sets is pending confirmation.
North Korea allegedly reused images from 2022 to claim a successful test of a cluster munition warhead on November 4. South Korea's Joint Chiefs of Staff reported detecting multiple missiles on the same day. The credibility of the photos is under scrutiny, as verification is needed to confirm the authenticity of the claims regarding the weapon system.
- North Korea distributed photos claiming to show a successful test of a cluster munition warhead.
- The photos allegedly reused images taken in 2022.
- South Korea's Joint Chiefs of Staff detected multiple missiles on the same day.
- The reliability of the photos is questioned due to potential image manipulation.
- The report emphasizes the need for triangulation of data from various sources.